• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Cardinal’s Pizza

At Cardinal’s Pizza, located in the heart of North Lewisburg, we celebrate the art of pizza-making with a dedication to flavor and quality. Our story is rooted in community and tradition, offering a variety of delicious options, from classic pies to unique offerings like our famed BLT pizza and health-conscious cauliflower crust. Customers rave about our barbecue wings and friendly service, making us a beloved local gem. With a welcoming atmosphere, outdoor seating, and catering services, Cardinal’s Pizza invites you to share memorable meals with family and friends, whether dining in or enjoying our convenient delivery and takeout options.

Cardinal’s Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Angela M.
Angela M.

Best whole in the wall pizza place. Their pizza is really good and so are their BBQ wings.. definitely recommend if coming into North Lewisburg!

Matt E.
Matt E.

Delicious pizza, subs, and French Bread. Service very friendly with delivery available. Highly recommend this local gem!

Dave C.
Dave C.

Truly great tasting pizza. I may be have a little bias. My cousins started Michaels pizza in Urbana. They truly created a great tasting combinations of crust, sauce, cheese and toppings. Cardinal Pizza is true to this flavor.

Rhonda B.
Rhonda B.

Always enjoy their pizza!! We have ordered several kinds of pizza! Always happy!! I currently am trying to eat healthier and they have a Cauliflower crust!!!

Kevin Z.
Kevin Z.

Do not hesitate to order the BLT pizza. Best one I have ever had. Super nice staff too.

Jason K.
Jason K.

After moving to the area we tried a number of pizza places but found Cardinal's Pizza to be by far the best. I can tell they use quality ingredients and do the necessary steps to make a great pizza. Also there are staff has such a positive energy when you walk in the door.q

Michelle C.
Michelle C.

Love supporting local businesses. Great tasting pizza & portion size. Friendly staff as well as great service if you choose to dine in. Yummy!

Misty W.
Misty W.

Cardinals is my favorite pizza place around! The pizzas are amazing especially the BLT! The management and workers are amazing! If you haven't tried cardinals your missing out!!

Cassie B.
Cassie B.

Bang for your buck: 7/10 Quality: 9/10 Service: 7.5/10 Ambiance/Location: 7/10 Overall: 8/10 BLT and Taco pizzas are the best! Nothing compares.

brandon m.
brandon m.

Crisp yet soft, chewy crust with a robust tomato-based sauce and cheese made from happy cows. Pizza doesn't get much more Midwestern than Cardinal's Pizza. The staff is friendly towards non-locals and first timers and I'm happy to make the 45 minute drive any day of the week. The locals say the Hawaiian is their favorite.

Location

Welcome to Cardinal’s Pizza, a delightful culinary gem nestled in North Lewisburg, Ohio. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and exceptional offerings, Cardinal’s has swiftly become the go-to destination for pizza aficionados and families alike. Located at 14 E Maple St, this unclaimed pizza haven perfectly captures the spirit of community dining.

What sets Cardinal’s Pizza apart? An array of exceptional utilities that cater to every dining requirement, including:

  • Delivery & Takeout: Enjoy your meals at home or on the go.
  • Reservations: Secure your spot for a special occasion.
  • Outdoor Seating: Savor your pizza under the Ohio sky.
  • Family-Friendly: A welcoming space for kids and groups.
  • Catering Services: Perfect for events and gatherings.
  • Wi-Fi & TV: Stay connected while enjoying your meal.
  • Alcohol Options: A refreshing selection to complement your pizza.

Patrons rave about the delicious combinations found within Cardinal’s menu. From the classic BBQ wings that leave you wanting more to signature pizzas that can satisfy every palate, there’s something for everyone. Customer Angela M. passionately declares it to be the "best hole-in-the-wall pizza place," while Matt E. emphasizes the friendly service and recommends their subs and French bread as must-tries.

If you’re looking for unique flavor profiles, the BLT pizza receives high praise from Kevin Z., heralded as "the best one" he's ever had. Additionally, for those with dietary preferences, Rhonda B. highlights the option of a Cauliflower crust, showcasing Cardinal’s commitment to accommodating all guests.

Cardinal’s Pizza excels not just in its menu offerings but also in its ambiance. The friendly staff ensures every visit is more than just a meal; it’s an experience to savor. As Dave C. puts it, the establishment echoes the rich flavors reminiscent of family pizza traditions, ensuring a genuine connection with every bite.

Whether you’re a local or just passing through North Lewisburg, Cardinal’s Pizza is an essential stop for anyone looking to indulge in great food. Call them at (937) 747-2606 to place your order or make a reservation today!